TL; DR: More than two years after our first trip to Islay, we are finally back! This time, with Mr Vantastic and two special companions, we visited (almost) all the distilleries we didn’t manage the first time, starting with one that, 2 years ago, was still a building site: Port Ellen! A very beautiful site, with an experimental twist. 

It is not by coincidence that Islay is called the Queen of the Hebrides. There is something magical about this island, and it is not just the whisky. Maybe it has to do with the effort and the long trip to get there (well, unless you fly from Glasgow), that will take you through the west of Scotland and then, after a 2-hour ferry trip, finally on the island! But yeah, once you know, you know.

Our last trip, in spring 2022, was quite unfortunate: the rented campervan broke, so we had to book last-minute accommodations and cabs. During the only walk we did, it pished down rain, so we were also wet and smelly. But somehow, we managed to visit all the six distilleries we’d scheduled (Bunnahabhain, Ardnahoe, Kilchoman, Bruichladdich, Lagavulin and Laphroaig).

This trip was a long time coming, we would have liked to make it back in 2023,  but we couldn’t. Another idea was to go earlier this year  (2024, if you’re reading in the future) but the plan fell apart (well, we went to the stunning Raasay instead!). What finally made us take the step was the reopening of Port Ellen distillery. It originally opened in 1825, and the whisky was mainly used in blends. It was closed down by DCL (Distillery Company Ltd) during the whisky loch of the 80s, so together with many others, it didn’t make it to the new millennium. In the meantime, however, the whisky became a cult among single malt lovers, particularly the well-aged expressions (according to some experts, their malt was not well regarded at young ages, one of the reasons for closing it down). Therefore, similarly to Brora (and Rosebank, by Ian McLeod), Diageo decided to revive it: basically, it was rebuilt from scratch, near the Port Ellen maltings, to the west of Port Ellen village. It started production earlier this year. It is open to visitors, but with Diageo being Diageo, the tour is astonishingly priced at £200 (two-fricking-hundred)! Unlike Brora though (where the two available tours costed respectively £350 and £600 the first time we drove by, now -July ’24- changed to £225 and £900, ludicrous), they offer a once-a-month open day (first Friday or Saturday of the month), running several free tours per day: yay!

We took advantage of it as soon as we could, and we booked a spot for the July open day, for us and our friend Justine (Kask Whisky). Because it was on a Friday, we organised the whole weekend around it, with visits to other distilleries too. A couple of weeks after we’d booked everything, Edo (Gianluigi’s youngest brother) told us he wanted to come visit in July, so he joined us too. He likes whisky, and according to Gianluigi, he has the best palate of the family (he’s an exceptional cook!). So there we were, on a Thursday morning, ready for our trip: at first the two of us, Edo, and Mr Vantastic, on the road.

Our ferry was booked for the evening, so we did a few stops in between: Fyne Ales brewery (always very tasty pints) and for lunch at Loch Fyne Oysters, pricey but the array of seafood we ate was exceptional! We also briefly stopped at the George Hotel, Inveraray, to say “hi” to our friend Ivan (and for Gianluigi and Edo to get a dram…Teresa was driving at that point). As we drove towards Kennacraig, the weather got worse, so much that they changed our destination, Port Askaig instead of Port Ellen (sad trombone sound). The wind was howling on Islay as well, but we drove straight to our parking for the night, while admiring some piles of peat drying out along the way. We parked our van next to Justine’s Post Dram Prat and had a small meal and a few drams (the Ardray, a new Suntory blended scotch, was the surprise of the evening), before slowly drifting to bed.

Because of the wind, which was still blowing in the morning, we couldn’t get much sleep…especially Edo, who slept in the pop-up roof. We woke up early and had breakfast at the van with Justine. We were a tad slow, so before our visit we didn’t do anything except packing up the van, but we still arrived early at the distillery. Indeed, we were the first ones there, and at first everything looked closed. Fortunately, about 10 minutes before the tour starting time, someone opened the door and checked us in: for the first tour they were waiting for other 14 people, so 18 in total!

As everybody arrived, we started the tour with Allan, the distillery manager. He is very experienced, as he worked on all the four Diageo sites on the island (3 distilleries and the maltings), so we were quite excited. He started by showcasing the installations in the visitor centre hall. A note here: we call it “visitor centre”, but it is clearly different from what we are used to, even in comparison to other Diageo recently renovated distilleries. It is very modern looking and bright, and there is no shop (unless it is upstairs, where we didn’t go). The clear intention was to set up something classy…However, in a clumsy way, as to us it looked like a fancy residence or office lobby.

One great feature, instead, is their use of mostly renewable sources for energy. The distillery was (re)built with the intention of making it as carbon neutral as possible, which is very valuable. As we moved to production, Allan showed us their permanent lab, which is quite unique: here, a full-time analyst checks the peat levels in the barley and the spirit, thus serving both the distillery and the maltings.

We then took a look at the mill room, a very large space with a very modern mill, which we expected as the site has been totally rebuilt (so no Porteous here!). Back to the main production room, we were right in front of the mashtun: a stainless-steel big baby, semi-Leuter, with a shiny lid.

At the moment, they do 11 mashes per week, mainly with Concerto barley but really with “whatever comes in”, and they have no silent season (except for maintenance, when required). They do mashes of different sizes, one of 5.5 tons for the experimental stills, and one of 7.5 tons for the regular stills (more on that later). With less water runs per mash, this is one of the steps where they save on water, which is common to many Diageo distilleries nowadays. The process is like sparging when brewing beer, in our understanding, with only one water gradually heated up. The wort is then moved to one of the six Oregon pine washbacks, each one with a capacity of 52,000 litres, but they never reach these levels. Fermentation lasts between 92 to 130 hours, quite a long one. Allan allowed us to nose the wash, and if we wanted taste it, but none of our party did.

Here is the interesting bit: the old stills that were in the distillery at the times of closing down in the 80s disappeared: they were sent to India and from there they lost track. So, the engineers at Diageo’s Abercrombie had to rely on drawings and sketches to recreate the new ones with the exact same shape. With these stills, the process is the usual: they run a double distillation, with the second cut taken after 25-30 minutes of foreshots, from 72-73% down to 60% (a large one!). The spirit is filled in both tankers and casks on site, usually diluted at 63.5%. However, they also have a second pair of stills, similar but smaller, that they use to experiment. The most interesting part is that instead of having the usual 3-part second distillation (foreshots or head, middle cut or heart, and low wines or tail; the first and last discarded and usually redistilled), the safe can separate out up to 10 different cuts, other than the discarded parts. These don’t get mixed together, and they are used to study and experiment how different cuts provide different flavours to the whisky, and in particular how this relates to the whisky peatiness and smokiness. We got to nose samples, and (maybe the power of suggestion) the difference was definitely there, in particular when comparing the first sample to the last.

After this, the tour ended. In general, the distillery manager giving the tour, and in particular the last bit, made the visit really worth it, even if we didn’t manage to try any sample (which we kind of expected). Overall, it was great to see this very beautiful new old distillery…We’d say we’re looking forward to the whisky in the coming years, but we know we’ll hardly be able to get it, if things stay the way they are now in terms of prices.

Stay tuned for more whisky action, and a little spoiler: we had to take another ferry! Until then, slainte!

---

Port Ellen Open Day

Price: free (open day, July 2024)

Duration: 1hr

Tasting: nope

Distillery exclusive: none

Target: locals and whisky nerds

Value for money: well, it’s freeee…

Highlights: the beautiful new architecture and the experimental stills

Recommended: yes if it’s the open day

Link: https://www.malts.com/en-row/distilleries/port-ellen

---